SIMULATION BASED APPRAISAL STUDY OF OSPF AND EIGRP FOR EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION NETWORK
Abstract
Today, internet is playing a vital role in communication networks and this computer communication networks are based on technology that provides technical infrastructure, where routing protocols are used to transmit packets across the network. The Open Systems Interconnection (OSI) reference model was created, to determine the compatibility of various connected devices for communication. The routing protocols are implemented in the network layer of the model, providing the set of rules for devices to route data packets towards the destination. This paper focuses on two (2) routing protocols: Open Shortest Path First (OSPF) and Enhanced Interior Gateway Routing Protocol (EIGRP) which is a member of Interior Gateway Protocol (IGP). Different protocols use different algorithms to route its packets and this affects the overall performance of the network. OSPF and EIGRP were used to distribute routing information between routers in the same autonomous system. Extensive experiments have been conducted to analyze and compare a set of characteristics of OSPF and EIGRP on an application like video Conferencing by using OPNET Modeler in an enterprise partial mesh network topology to determine the best protocol for a fast network convergence. Hence, this research simulates three network topologies and the results clearly show that EIGRP converges faster than OSPF and also EIGRP has the least Point to Point Queuing Delay than OSPF.
References
Chandra, W. (2011) Performance Analysis of Dynamic Routing Protocol EIGRP and OSPF in IPv4 and IPv6 Network. Proceedings on First International Conference on Informatics Computational Intelligence. 5(2), 355 – 360.
Chris, K. W. (2006) Tuning Dynamically Routed Internet Protocol Network to achieve Controlled and Predictable Failover during Link Instability. 5(2), 1059.
Farhangi, S. etal (2012) Performance Comparison of mixed protocols based on EIGRP, IS-IS and OSPF for real-time applications. Middle Eastern Journal of Scientific Research. 12(11), 65-70.
George F.R., Talam, J., Dheeraj, R. (2006) Simulation-based Routing Protocol Performance Analysis, Proceedings of the 2006 winter simulation conference.
Kurose, J.F., Ross, K.W. (2010) Computer Networking, a top-down approach. Boston Pearson Education Inc.
Labovitz, C., Ahuja, A., Jaliaman, F. (2000) Delayed Internet Routing convergence. SIGCOMM Computer Communication. Rev., 30:175-187.
Leahy, E. (2011) EIGRP-packets and neigborship (Retrieved) 18-11-2013.
Mirza, W. H., Sanjay, J. (2016) Comaparative Analysis of various Routing Protocols. Internal Journal of Modern Engineering Research, 6(68).
Mirzahossein, k., et al. (2013) Analysis of RIP, OSPF and EIGRP routing protocols using OPNET. Simon Fraser University, School of Engineering Science.
Nikolaidis, I. (2002) Cisco IP Routing (book review). Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineering (IEEE) Network 16(2).
Sendra, S., et al (2010) Study and performance of interior gateway IP routing protocols. Network Protocols and Algorithms 2(4).
Thorenoor, S.G. (2010) Dynamic routing protocol implementation decision between EIGRP,OSPF and RIP based on technical background using OPNET modeler (Wipro technology,Bangalore,india). Proceeding of the 2010 second international conference on compiler and network technology (ICCNT 2010), 191-195.
Todd, L. (2005) CISCO Certified Network Associates. 5th (Ed.).
Todd, L. (2007) Cisco Certified Network Associate Study Guide. 6th (Ed.), Wiley Publishing inc., USA., ISBN-13:9780470110089.
Wagas, A. (2009) An empirical study to observe route recoverability performance of routing Protocols in Real Time Communication.
Copyright (c) 2023 FUDMA JOURNAL OF SCIENCES
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
FUDMA Journal of Sciences